Whether it’s a new home, renovation, or collaboration with your architect, we’d love to hear from you.
Reach out and let’s talk about how we can make your project a reality.
The contract decides who carries the risk when costs move. Here's how both types really work, where blowouts come from, and how to pick the right one for your build.
Ask anyone who's built a home what scared them most, and you'll hear the same thing. The budget blowing out. The fixed price vs cost plus contract question in NSW is really a question about that fear: when costs move, who pays?
Neither contract is a trick, and neither is automatically safer. They split the risk differently. Here's the straight version of how each one works, where the surprises hide, and what NSW law says before you sign.
A fixed price contract sets the price for the documented work when you sign, and the builder carries the risk of their own costs running over. It's the most common contract for new homes. The price can still move through variations, allowances and certain site conditions, so read those clauses as closely as the number on page one.
The appeal is obvious. You know what you're paying, the bank knows what it's lending against, and the builder has every reason to run the job efficiently. Many lenders prefer a fixed price contract for a construction loan, so check with yours early.
A fixed price is only as good as the drawings behind it. The more complete the design and specification, the fewer gaps there are for allowances to fill. Half-finished drawings produce a fixed price full of guesses.
Every fixed price has edges. Common ones are site conditions nobody could see, like rock or soft ground, plus council conditions that arrive after signing, and anything the drawings don't show.
None of that is unusual. But a contract that excludes a lot is a lot less fixed than it looks. Ask your builder to walk you through every exclusion and what it could cost if it comes up.
That's why we always say finish the design before you price it. If you're working with an architect, it's worth knowing how architects and builders should work together so the documents are ready to price properly.
A cost plus contract has no guaranteed final price. You pay the builder's actual, verified costs for the work, plus an agreed margin or fee, usually in regular claims as the job goes. You carry the risk if costs rise, but you also see every cost. It suits work that's hard to price upfront.
The NSW Government's Consumer Building Guide describes it the same way. It also says it's good practice for the builder to give you a non-binding estimate before starting, then track costs against that budget with you.
Honestly, cost plus isn't the scary option it's sometimes made out to be. But it does ask more of you. You need to read the cost reports, ask questions and stay on top of decisions.
The difference comes down to who carries the cost risk. With a fixed price, the builder wears most of it, so the price includes a buffer for it. With cost plus, you wear it, so you pay only what the job actually costs. Everything in the table below follows from that.
| What you're comparing | Fixed price | Cost plus |
|---|---|---|
| Price at signing | Set for the documented work, with allowances | Not known, ideally with a written estimate |
| Who carries cost risk | Mostly the builder | Mostly you |
| How you pay | Progress claims at set stages | Regular claims for verified costs plus margin |
| Changes you ask for | Priced as variations | Added to the running cost |
| What you see | The price, not the builder's costs | Every invoice and cost |
| Best suited to | A fully documented design | Work that's hard to scope upfront |
Look, there's no prize for picking the "right" one in the abstract. The right contract is the one that matches how finished your design is and how much uncertainty is left in the job.
And in either case, hold a contingency. We recommend 10% to 15% on top of the contract, which we explain in our 2026 guide to building costs in the Northern Rivers.
Most fixed price blowouts come from allowances. Prime cost items are allowances for things you haven't chosen yet, like a sink or tapware. Provisional sums cover work that can't be priced yet, like excavation where there might be rock. When the real cost beats the allowance, you pay the difference, usually plus margin.
Here's a simple example from the HIA's guide to prime cost and provisional sums in NSW. If the allowance for a sink is $500 and you choose one costing $700, the extra $200 is added to the price, plus the builder's margin.
One sink is nothing. Twenty allowances that were all set low is how a fixed price drifts by tens of thousands.
It can work the other way too. If you choose something that costs less than its allowance, the difference usually comes off the price. Check how your contract handles that, because it's easy to miss when everything else seems to be going up.
Variations are the other big mover. Anything you change after signing is priced as a variation. In NSW, variations should be agreed in writing before the work is done, so ask for every one on paper with its cost, before anyone picks up a tool.
10%: the most a builder can take as a deposit on residential building work in NSW.
Home Building Act 1989 (NSW)
For most new homes with a finished design, a fixed price contract makes sense. It gives you a clear number and puts the cost risk on the builder. Cost plus suits work that's genuinely hard to scope, or a complex home where a fixed price would be mostly allowances anyway.
Plenty of new builds land somewhere in between. The house is priced as a fixed price, and the genuinely uncertain parts, like excavation on a rocky block, sit in clearly defined provisional sums.
That gives you a firm number for most of the job and honesty about the rest. It works well when the provisional sums are realistic and few, and when you know exactly how they'll be measured.
Whichever you choose, the builder matters more than the contract type. A good builder on a fixed price will be upfront about allowances. A good builder on cost plus will report clearly and flag overruns early. Our guide on how to choose a builder in NSW covers what to look for.
Before you sign, check the contract shows the price or a clear warning that it isn't known, that allowances look realistic, and that variations need written agreement. On work over $20,000, NSW requires a written contract and home building compensation insurance before any deposit. The deposit itself is capped at 10%.
The NSW Government's guide to building contracts sets out the rules and has a checklist for owners. It's worth reading start to finish before you sign anything.
Whichever contract you sign, payments should line up with work actually done on site. A claim for a stage that hasn't been reached is a red flag. So is pressure to pay ahead to secure materials or a start date.
And get independent advice. A construction lawyer can read a contract in a few hours, and that's a small cost next to a dispute that can run for years.
If you're still at the start of the journey, our guide to building a home in the Northern Rivers walks through what comes before the contract.
If you're weighing up contracts for a new home anywhere in Byron Shire or the Northern Rivers, we're keen to chat. We'll walk you through exactly how we'd price your build, what's an allowance, and why.
Start Your BuildMostly, but not completely. The price can move through variations you ask for, prime cost items and provisional sums that come in over their allowances, and site conditions the contract allows for. Read those sections closely. A fixed price is only as fixed as its allowances and exclusions.
Yes. Cost plus contracts are used for home building work in NSW. For work over $20,000, the contract has to show the price or carry a warning that the price isn't known, with an explanation of how it's worked out. A good builder also gives you a written estimate and tracks costs against it.
A provisional sum is an allowance for work the builder can't price exactly when you sign, like excavation where there might be rock. If the real cost comes in higher, you usually pay the difference plus the builder's margin. Ask how each provisional sum was estimated, and push for realistic numbers.
For residential building work in NSW, the deposit is capped at 10% of the contract price. On work over $20,000, the builder must also give you a certificate of home building compensation insurance before taking any money or starting work. If either is missing, stop and ask why before you pay.
Family-run custom builder based in Ocean Shores, building architectural new homes with architects and designers across Byron Shire and the Northern Rivers.
Whether it’s a new home, renovation, or collaboration with your architect, we’d love to hear from you.
Reach out and let’s talk about how we can make your project a reality.
I can’t speak highly enough of this building company. They recently completed two outstanding projects on my luxury villas in Byron Bay, taking over from a previous builder who unfortunately wasn’t doing the right thing.
The team stepped into a difficult situation, taking on a site that was in poor shape and quickly transforming it into a truly spectacular build that we’re all extremely proud of. From day one, they were a pleasure to work with. A great group of young local tradesman who are honest, reliable, and genuinely care about the quality of their work
Salisbury Building projects built us the most incredible home. The experienced team lead by Murphy are all super friendly and nice to have around. Murphy is knowledgeable and knows how to resolve issues and build to a high standard. Defects are all recognised and fixed even after the completion without any problem. He has a strong local network of trades and is well liked so there was no wait on trades.
The house was completed so quickly. We cannot recommend Salisbury Building projects enough and are so impressed with the result.
The results and photos speak for themselves.
What you cant see is that any large project involves the building team being involved with your own family for a long time. Salisbury building is a family run business that show respect to each other and the client at all times while striving to produce the highest quality product.
Murphy and the boys have transformed the way we will live in and enjoy our house and it was a pleasure to have them as part of our family for a short time.